Why Industrial Outdoor Storage Is So Hard to Replace in Madison
Industrial outdoor storage in Madison can significantly influence a property’s value. A 9,900 SF industrial building built in 2017 sold for $2.25 million earlier this year. At roughly $227 per square foot, that is a high price for a Madison industrial building of that size.
The former Sutton Transport terminal at 3841 Merchant Street sits on 3.44 acres, with 21 dock-high doors, 25 trailer parking stalls and a large paved yard. The buyer, a food distributor, valued the property’s outdoor space and loading infrastructure.
Oakbrook’s Chris Caulum, SIOR, explained the pricing and marketing strategy in a case study of the Merchant Street sale.
Much of the property’s utility was outside the building. The combination of land, pavement, access and approvals can be difficult and expensive to recreate.
Why Outdoor Storage Is Getting National Attention
The Wall Street Journal reported on October 26, 2026, that institutional investors are increasingly buying industrial outdoor storage (IOS) properties. Data center construction is contributing to demand for yards that accommodate equipment, trucks and materials. National IOS rents have increased 32% since 2021, according to figures cited in the article.
Madison’s IOS demand looks different. Contractors, trucking companies, equipment suppliers and distributors are important local users. Data center-related construction is contributing to industrial activity in Dane County, but it is not the primary driver of the IOS market.
Vacant Land Is Not Yard Space
A parcel can have plenty of acreage and still be unsuitable for outdoor storage.
Zoning comes first. In Madison, outdoor storage is generally regulated as an accessory use rather than a stand-alone principal use. It is allowed in certain industrial zoning districts, subject to requirements. A vacant parcel without an associated permitted use may not qualify.
Madison also imposes screening and placement requirements. Depending on the zoning district and surrounding uses, outdoor storage may require fencing or screening between six and eight feet high, restrictions on stacking heights and separation from residential properties.
Existing approvals deserve attention. A yard operating for decades may have legal nonconforming status or approvals tied to a particular use. Expanding or changing that use can trigger additional review.
Physical characteristics narrow the options further. Trucks need room to enter, maneuver, load and exit. Setbacks, stormwater facilities, turning radii and driveway locations can consume substantial portions of a site.
Location influences demand, too. Many IOS users want convenient access to the Beltline or Interstates 39, 90 and 94.
Then there is the development cost. Grading, pavement or gravel, drainage, fencing, gates and lighting can require substantial investment. An existing yard with suitable improvements and approvals can avoid considerable expense and uncertainty.
Industrial Outdoor Storage in Madison: What We Are Seeing
Madison’s industrial vacancy rate was 3.3% in Q2 2026, with approximately 323,700 SF of positive net absorption. Read Oakbrook’s Q2 industrial market update.
Functional outdoor storage is even harder to find. Most of the more than 800 industrial buildings Oakbrook tracks in the Madison market have little or no usable yard space.
We are seeing that shortage through several recent assignments.
6371-6399 Nesbitt Road, Fitchburg. Oakbrook represented the buyer of the former County Materials property this fall. The new owner is clearing debris, regrading portions of the site, renovating buildings worth retaining and removing others.
The plan is to lease outdoor storage areas as small as one acre. Early inquiries have been encouraging, particularly from businesses needing one or two secure acres, with or without building space.
OM Station, Madison. At the former Oscar Mayer property, Oakbrook is marketing outdoor storage areas ranging from approximately half an acre to five acres alongside industrial building space. Most of the yard is already leased, although shorter lease terms may create future opportunities.
Our assignments have also included representing an equipment-industry buyer seeking a rural industrial property with outdoor storage capabilities.
Trucking companies, contractors and equipment suppliers frequently need substantially more yard than building area. Finding the right combination of usable land, access, location and permitted use can be difficult.
Based on the searches and leasing activity we are seeing, demand for functional IOS sites in Dane County exceeds the available supply.
What Owners Should Know Before Making a Change
Owners with existing outdoor storage should understand what they have before selling, redeveloping or changing their property’s use.
An evaluation should start with zoning and existing approvals, followed by usable acreage, access, surface conditions, drainage and supporting building space. Those characteristics influence market rental rates and sale value.
Our work at Merchant Street, Nesbitt Road and OM Station has involved different IOS property types, buyers and tenants. Each required evaluating how the outdoor space could be used and what prospective users would pay for it.
For property owners, the question is whether the existing yard has greater value in its current configuration than under an alternative use, particularly when replacing those improvements could be expensive or difficult to permit.
Key Takeaways
- Outdoor storage value comes as much from the site, pavement and existing approvals as from building square footage.
- Zoning restrictions, permitting requirements and development costs make new outdoor storage yards difficult to create in the Madison area.
- Truck circulation, drainage and access can reduce usable yard space well below a property’s total acreage.
- Demand for functional outdoor storage exceeds available supply in Dane County, particularly for businesses seeking one or two acres of secure yard space.
- Existing improvements and approvals can significantly influence an industrial property’s rental rates and sale value.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is industrial outdoor storage?
Industrial outdoor storage (IOS) is land used to store trucks, trailers, equipment or materials outside, often with limited building space. Trucking companies, contractors, equipment suppliers and distributors are typical users.
Why is IOS hard to find in Madison?
Zoning restrictions, screening requirements and limited industrial land make suitable outdoor storage difficult to find. Many existing industrial properties also lack sufficient usable yard space.
Can I use vacant industrial land for outdoor storage?
Not automatically. The zoning district, permitted uses, existing approvals and site characteristics determine whether outdoor storage is allowed and practical. Property owners should verify these requirements before assuming vacant acreage can be used for storage.
How does outdoor storage affect a property’s value?
A permitted, improved yard can significantly increase an industrial property’s value. The sale of 3841 Merchant Street for approximately $227 per square foot of building space demonstrates how paved yard space, loading infrastructure and trailer parking can contribute to a property’s appeal to buyers.
What should an owner do before selling a property with a yard?
Confirm permitted uses and existing approvals, evaluate usable yard space and assess the condition of site improvements. Understanding replacement costs, market demand and comparable sales can help owners evaluate their property’s potential value.
If you own an industrial property with outdoor storage, or your business is searching for yard space in Dane County, Oakbrook’s industrial services team can help evaluate the market and available options.
Sean Ruhly
Commercial Real Estate Advisor
Sean Ruhly works with business owners, investors, tenants, and developers on office, industrial, and vacant land real estate throughout Southern Wisconsin. His work includes sales and leasing support, market research, site selection, property analysis, and transaction execution.
608-838-3100
sruhly@oakbrookcorp.com
Meet Sean Ruhly

